Vayelech | 5 Tishrei 5781 | September 11th, 2021 | Issue 910

This edition is dedicated
in loving memory of
Miriam Rivka bat Chaim z"
Mordechai Yosef ben Yitzchak David Friedland z"l
Menashe z"l ben Mordechai Yosef z"l and Miriam Friedland
What is in this week's newsletter

'One Who Loves Tanach'

A short Dvar Torah for Parashat Vayelech (5 min)

Gotta Learn Torah!

For more weekly videos join a quiet WhatsApp group
Watch Here!

Some Jewish Lessons Twenty Years After 9-11

Rabbi Michael J. Broyde
Community Rabbi and Rosh Kollel, Atlanta

Click Here for the PDF version

This Shabbat returns many of us to the tragic events of 20 year ago (whose secular anniversary corresponds to this week’s parsha of וילך, September 11, 2001) when Al-Qaida hijacked four planes, attacked the Pentagon, and destroyed the World Trade Center. That morning set the course of many United States foreign and domestic policies that we still live with today, two decades later.

It was also a deeply personal tragedy for the families of the almost 3,000 killed, most of whom were unable to recover the bodies of their loved ones from under the charred ruble, and the over 6,000 wounded. 

Calamities are national and tragedies more personal.  Every national disaster has both.  

The impact of the foreign policy wrought on the United States in response to the attacks misses how global events impact individuals’ personal tragedies.  9-11 was such an event for New York, and in particular its Orthodox community.  The destruction of the Twin Towers, and the horrible and anonymous deaths that resulted, reoriented many people to focus on the disaster of the day. 

That was certainly true in the Beth Din of America. The Beth Din of America was a called upon to be involved in many of the sad situation that arose out of 9-11: identifying the remains of men who had disappeared when the Towers fell, collecting clear and distinct proof that they had died, and writing letters that authorized their wives to remarry as a matter of Jewish law.

Jewish law – deeply cognizant of cases where a husband was thought to be dead but was still alive – codified a set of simple rules to prevent cases in which a man would be designated as dead who was still alive.  In essence, these three rules allowed one to establish death in the following situations:  

  • First, where there is actual physical evidence of death.

  • Second, where there are witnesses to the death.

  • Third, where a person was placed, with certainty, in a situation in which no one could survive, such as a burning furnace.

Importantly, death could not be determined by statistical evidence that most people in any given situation died. The reason is obvious: claiming 99% of the people in this situation died is an acknowledgment that some survived.  To put it in practical terms, the cost of a false negative, was very high and the Talmudic rabbis decreed that each case of a husband’s presumed passing in which there was no body was to be investigated to insure that there actually was a death, before the wife would be allowed to remarry. 

In the cases after the Twin Towers fell, there were rarely direct witnesses, as they too perished.  There were some cases where people could be placed in a situation – like on a plane that crashed into the Towers – where escape was impossible. And then there was DNA evidence of death, which needed to be closely examined.

In the face of tragedy and evil, there are naturally two responses.  One is to help the victim of the wrong and the second is to punish the evil-doer and make sure the wrong does not happen again.  I have always viewed the work done after 9-11 by rabbinical courts, and in particular the Beth Din of America, as providing a form of comfort and closure to the deceased – helping the victim of the wrong, by allowing them to seek closure in the face of tragedy.  Families of victims – who were frequently left with no body to bury and no funeral to attend – were given a letter with a yahrzeit date and assurances that now is a proper time to start mourning. Widows were given permission to remarry.  This same process was followed by Rabbi Ovadia Yosef in the case of many missing soldiers after the Yom Kippur was, as many have recounted.

Of course, there were deep advances in Jewish law through this process – authorities of Jewish law became familiar with DNA technology in a way they never had before and details of a host of new technologies were examined from the lenses of classical halacha. Responsa (teshuvot) were written on a variety of technological advances as well as complex evidentiary problems that came up during these cases. For example, how definitive was the phone companies placement of the location of a call from a cell phone in 2001, and how accurate are dental records, really.  Countless technical matters of halacha were updated in light of the technology that advanced in the last half-century.

Still, the core of the work that was done was an act of compassion to the men, women and children who lost loved ones in a murderous act. They needed closure, a need that was met by the Beth Din of America in every case its opinion was sought.


For more Divrei Torah on the parsha click here

2020-21 Alumni Gathering

Last week we were excited to meet the Bachurim who recently finished a unique year of shlichut.
It was an opportunity for the bachurim to share experiences and also for us to thank them for their amazing work over the past year.

Like every year, were were honored to host Dudi and Shoshana Yaverboim, whose son, Ayal hy"d, was our shaliach in Montevideo. Ayal was killed in a terrorist attack in the settlement Negohot on Rosh Hashana 18 years ago. They gave every alumnus a copy of the book "Zechuyot Karimon", a compilation of articles on the simanim of Rosh Hashana written in Ayal's memory.

We wish all our returning shlichim and easy acclimation back in Israel. May you find the way to continue your shlichut here in Israel!

And they're off!
Sending Yechiel Hexter and Michael Akerman to shlichut in Montreal
and Aharon Raanan off to Memphis.
Be a Partner in Spreading Torat Eretz Israel!
Donate Here

Torah MiTzion was established in 1995 with the goal of strengthening Jewish communities around the globe and infusing them with love for Torah, the Jewish People and the State of Israel.

Over the past 25 years more than 1,500 shlichim and shlichot have inspired and enriched their host communities through high impact formal and informal educational programs.


Like on Facebook

Our friend Benjy Singer has a very useful website,, which contains accurate and fresh information of what's going on in the Religious Anglo Community in Israel.


This email was sent to <<email>>
why did I get this?    unsubscribe from this list    update subscription preferences
Torah MiTzion · King George · 54 · Jerusalem 71109 · Israel