October-December 2018 events listing
View this email in your browser
Ciara Molloy

 Ireland’s last witchcraft trial: Islandmagee, 1711

 Monday 29 October, 8.00 p.m., Offaly History Centre, Tullamore

(We will give a prize for the best dressed witch on the night!)
The Islandmagee case of 1711 in Co. Antrim was Ireland’s last mass witchcraft trial, and this paper will examine the case from an overarching legal perspective in order to evaluate whether or not it can be regarded as a miscarriage of justice. The distinction provided by Clive Walker between a direct miscarriage of justice, which stems from the procedure of the trial itself, and an indirect miscarriage of justice resulting from a fabricated accusation, offers a useful blueprint.This paper will first provide a background to the operation of the legal system in early eighteenth-century Ireland, followed by the application of Walker’s five criteria for a direct miscarriage of justice to the trial. Additional contingent sources of unfairness such as jury-packing, the summing-up process of the trial judges, and the issue of ethnoreligious exclusivity will also be considered. However, this paper will conclude that from a procedural perspective the trial was largely just, despite sources of bias generated by the practice of jury-packing. Following this, the paper will examine the details and anomalies of this case to evaluate whether it may be regarded as an indirect miscarriage of justice. The existing evidence overwhelmingly suggests that the allegations made by the complainant Mary Dunbar were false, and were largely targeted at one of the defendants Margaret Mitchell. This new insight into the Islandmagee case reveals that this seemingly inexplicable case was most likely rooted in interpersonal tensions, with earthly rather than supernatural forces at play. Overall though, as a miscarriage of justice is primarily concerned with the legal procedure of the trial, it is difficult to classify this case as unjust despite the fabricated nature of the accusations.

Ciara Molloy is well-known to members as one of leading young historians and from Tullamore.

  • 22 October Joachim Fischer’s lecture scheduled for this date on German visitors to Ireland the Irish Midlands from 1750 has been postponed to March 2019.
  • 11 November at the Tullamore Central Library at 2.30 p.m. Launch of the society’s publication, Offaly and the Great War and readings from the essays by some of the contributors. See the invitation enclosed with this bulletin. The chief executive of Offaly County Council, Anna Marie Delaney, will launch the publication.
  • 17 November Heritage Seminar.  Details to follow in November.
  • 26 November, Monday, 8 p.m. Michael Byrne on King’s County/Offaly in a time of war, 1914-18, an illustrated lecture. This lecture has been deferred in view of the book launch on 11 November to which all the members have been invited. The book will also be launched in Edenderry and Birr in November.
  • 13 December, Thursday, 8 p.m.  at Offaly History Centre,  Christmas Meeting with an illustrated talk by Ciarán Reilly on The history of Capard House in Slieve Bloom. Followed by Christmas refreshments.
Copyright © 2018 Offaly Historical & Archaeological Society, All rights reserved.

View our previous newsletters

Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list

Email Marketing Powered by Mailchimp