October 8, 2015
Welcome to the Preemption Watch News. We hope you find these links, excerpts, and summaries useful. Please let us know if you have any news about proposed or pending preemption that you would like us to include in future updates. You can contact us at or (510) 452-9419. More information can be found at Preemption Thank you for your support!


Schrader, Merkley Back Chemical Policy Reform
The Lund Report, 10/5/15 
A bill passed in the U.S. House of Representatives and debate imminent over a bill in the U.S. Senate would bring Congress closer than ever before to reforming chemical regulation. If passed, the law would update federal authority to regulate chemicals that pose a risk to human and environmental health; however, it is also poised to curtail state authority to protect the public from hazardous exposures.
S.697 - Frank R. Lautenberg Chemical Safety for the 21st Century Act
A risky proposition: The ‘regulatory hole you could drive a train through’
Al Jazeera America, 9/28/15
In December 2012, Delli Priscoli finally unveiled his plans to more than 100 residents at a meeting in the municipal gym. The railroad yard, he announced, was to become a propane transfer, or transloading, facility, meaning that propane would be taken there by rail and unloaded onto tanker trucks to be distributed. With four 120-foot-long, 80,000-gallon storage tanks to be filled by up to 2,000 train tank cars a year, it would be the biggest rail propane facility in Massachusetts.
Residents were dumbfounded: The location was in the middle of a residential neighborhood, less than 2,000 feet from an elementary school and atop the town’s water supply…
And as residents would learn, it was the railroad’s position that it didn’t have to: Being a railroad, the Grafton & Upton was exempt from any state or local law that interfered with its business, a legal doctrine known as pre-emption.
As one resident put it, “You mean we have no rights?”


Tempe councilwoman sues state over plastic bag pre-emption
Arizona Daily Sun, 10/1/15
Calling the law an illegal intrusion on local affairs, a Tempe council member is asking a judge to void a new state law that blocks cities from regulating plastic and paper bags.
And Bisbee has decided to ignore the law entirely. In Flagstaff, at least one member of the City Council is likely to ask her colleagues to vote on joining the lawsuit.

Colorado Supreme Court to hear city fracking-ban cases
The Colorado Statesman, 9/24/15
The Colorado Supreme Court this week agreed to decide two citizen-driven anti-fracking cases that will go a long way toward determining the future of oil and gas drilling across Colorado.
In both cases — a five-year moratorium on fracking imposed by Fort Collins and an outright fracking ban in Longmont — industry and state officials contend that Colorado law preempts local regulations limiting drilling operations.

Guest commentary: Protect health, welfare foremost in oil drilling legislation
Naples Daily News, 10/6/15
According to materials presented by county staff, at least 23 Florida counties and municipalities have passed resolutions supporting a statewide ban on fracking; the number is much higher if one includes county and city resolutions to prohibit fracking within their communities.
Unfortunately, state Sen. Garrett Richter's 2014 bill included "prohibiting a county, municipality, or other political subdivision of the state from adopting or establishing permitting programs for certain oil and gas activities." It appears the 2016 bill is slated to include similar language — a pre-emption position unacceptable to the League.

Senator defends oil legislation
News-Press, 10/6/15
Coverage of Florida State Senator Garret Richter (R-Naples) defending his oil and gas preemption legislation.
Several bills focused on fracking could surface in January
Naples News, 9/29/15
State lawmakers once again have filed legislation aimed at regulating hydraulic fracturing, but the most recent version of the bill would significantly limit the amount of control local governments have in regulating oil exploration.
The measure (HB 191), sponsored by Rep. Ray Rodrigues and filed on Sept. 17, increases penalties, creates a chemical disclosure registry and requires well operators to obtain permits before they begin hydraulic fracturing in Florida. Sen. Garrett Richter, R-Naples, is sponsoring a similar measure (SB 318) in the state Senate.

SB 318

Special Event
Join us on October 14th2-3pm ET/1-2pm CT/11am-12pm PT for a #GrassrootsChange Twitter Chat about the national Paid Sick Days movement. We will hear directly from three key leaders of the Paid Sick Days movement about how they were able to build their movement and overcome preemption. They will share lessons from their movement strategies and the benefits of building an authentic grassroots movement for policy change.

Featured speakers:

Ellen Bravo, Executive Director, Family Values @ Work, @FmlyValuesWork@Ellen_Bravo

Melissa Josephs, Director of Equal Opportunity Policy, Women Employed, @WomenEmployed@MelissaJosephs

Vicki Shabo, Vice President, National Partnership for Women & Families, @PaidSickDays@NPWF
Join the chat on October 14: #GrassrootsChange, @GCpublichealth

                                Mark Pertschuk                                                   Michael Bare                               
                             Director                                                    Program Manager                   
Grassroots Change supports grassroots public health and safety movements. We’re joined together by a shared belief in the power of grassroots movements and a commitment to improving the lives of all Americans – whether that means access to healthy foods, violence prevention, paid sick days, or reconnecting children with nature. Preemption Watch is a project of Grassroots Change.
Grassroots Change
221 Oak Street, Oakland, CA 94607
(510) 452-9419 |
Support for this project is provided by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.

 unsubscribe from this list | update your subscription preferences